Obviously, the interviewer is implying about loyalty to the state (“state” as in country, not a US State) or to an administration, and I know that they are implying that. But I am not loyal to an administration. But I know that’s what they actually meant.

How would the polygraph interpret it if I say “Yes”, because I’m answering based on my interpretation of loyalty to the constitution, but deep down, I full well know the implied question the interviewer is asking.

🤔

  • Kazumara@discuss.tchncs.de
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    5
    ·
    2 days ago

    Since the others tackled polygraph’s uselessness, I want to comment on another angle:

    I think fundamentally in such a case it will be easy for you to convince yourself that you’re telling the truth in the moment you say it.

    After all you are telling the truth to a version of the question, and you only have an assumption that the questioner means a different version of the question. Even if it’s a good assumption, nothing in particular makes your version worse, in fact you could argue it’s better.

    That combined should make it easy to mentally gloss over the contradiction. So I think your physiological reaction will be indistinguishable from telling the truth on control questions.